Portland’s Creative Should Live Out Loud

Posted by Kim Brater on June 17, 2009
Advertising, Agency Life, Creative View, Marketers, Marketing, Our Community, Portland
Photo courtesy of www.portlandground.com

Photo courtesy of www.portlandground.com

I love Portland. We’re not the city that never sleeps. We’re not the windy city. And, we’re not filled with tinsel, bleached hair and botox. But, we are overshadowed by other cities, especially when it comes to creative – and that’s a shame (or a sham depending on how you look at it). Creativity thrives here in our fair City of Roses (regardless of what Fast Company thinks). And with more than 1,500 companies, large and small, in the creative services industry, we contribute a fair share of professional services business revenue and jobs. Yet for some reason, we’re afraid to toot the horn let alone blow a low whistle (a little music once in a while is okay people). Maybe we think we’re great but need proof. Or we’re overly modest. Either way, consider this:

  1. Creative services industry employs roughly 15,000 people in Portland
  2. We have 344 designers per 100K residents – more than LA and Austin (according to Bureau of Labor Stats ‘08 in Greater Portland Prosperity 2009)
  3. The creative vitality here (based on the National Creative Vitality Index - yes there is such a thing) is more than twice the national baseline
  4. Portland is among one of the most innovative cities, ranked 6 by Forbes for most patents, and 6th for both entrepreneurship and small business (Creative Capacity Project)
  5. Creative industries generate nearly $2 billion and a payroll of nearly $1 billion annually (that’s no chump change) (Creative Capacity Project)
  6. More than half of Oregon’s creative firms are concentrated in Portland (Creative Capacity Project)

Portland is a great place to be – to live and work. But we know that already. Even though we’re pushing through a rough spot and our state has one of the highest unemployment rates in the country, we don’t have the brain drain other cities are facing. In fact, we’ve got some brain gain going on. More people are moving here from out-of-state than to our western compatriots (that’d be Seattle, Albuquerque, Austin, San Diego, Denver, San Jose, San Francisco, Los Angeles and Sacremento). The region is a magnet for all kinds of talented professionals – a chunk of them in the the creative industry and they’d rather be here than someplace else. Some get the entrepreneurial bug. It’s quite catchy here. Some freelance for local agencies or work directly with clients and supplement with other jobs. Baristas or bartenders are common, but more often they are artists, writers and musicians. Perhaps this is why Forbes dubbed Portland one of the best metro areas in which to ride out the recession. The great coffee, local microbrews, top notch wineries, and growing spirit distillers are definitely a bonus. And innovation abounds (the coffee, beer, wine, and spirits help) with the booming food scene, developing clean/green tech industry, the variety of arts and yes, our creative services industry. There’s no doubt the quality of life here is a big pull for newbies and the anchor for those of us here.  But to keep all this quiet, to simply sit idle hoping the great creative work gets noticed, isn’t the best strategy to help grow an industry sector. We all want good clients whether they reside here locally or in other regions – and other regions are touting their creative (some quite loudly).

So, what makes Portland such a great creative place? I posed this question (on Twitter) to fellow Portlanders and here’s a short list of what they said:

Portland is a great creative city because there are no rules. @DanFellini

Because Portlanders are real people. The lack of restriction and openness promotes a more creative and less stifled spirit. @massagepdx

It’s not that I don’t play well with others; I just want to choose where, when and with whom I play. [It's the] PDX attitude. @LogoMotives

Despite local chagrin, the influx of creatives from all over the country converging here brings broad perspective. @Metroknow

I have mixed feelings about it as a creative city. It’s like a college graduate: full of potential. Now it needs to find its way. @swestbrook

PDXers are curious and not too self-obsessed. Our lives are generally balanced and we leave room for non-work projects. We’re generally tolerant and open to new ideas=innovation. We’re risk takers and revel in a good fail-as-learning experience. @thisKat

Portland creativity=cuz we have twice the creative fuel with half the financial pressure. @vizeboogie

Because in PDX, there is life other than work, and that drives us to be more creative and inspired. @KevMurphy

We are passionate about living. We are free spirits. We celebrate…our ability to listen to ideas that we might not hold dear to ourselves. We live our lives out loud. @dtboyd

It’s this last point, living out loud, that strikes home.  Portland should take pride in our creative abilities and capabilities and not be afraid to shout them to the world.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

17 Comments to Portland’s Creative Should Live Out Loud

Justin
June 17, 2009

I think these are all great points, where was this in the Rosey campaign?

Instead of using that campaign to point out how great portland is, or how bright our future is, we turned it into a pissing match that left Portland looking like Kermit the Frog talking shit to Lebron James on the basket ball court. Silly. Let’s take a look at some of the tweets you posted:

“PDXers are curious and not too self-obsessed.”
“We are free spirits. We celebrate…our ability to listen to ideas that we might not hold dear to ourselves.”
“Because in PDX, there is life other than work”

Again, all great points that are rendered moot by the Rosey campaign. At the end of the day, this isn’t the end of the world: this is an awards show for local players, and frankly, my friends in many of the cities this campaign rips on are too busy with their accounts Portland isn’t remotely prepared to take on to even give a damn. But I left a job in Brooklyn to work in Portland because I love living here and because I believe this city can and will be important in the creative industry. Instead of talk, lets bring the fire! Lets bring the work that will show everyone we’re for real instead of telling them we are.

Ryan
June 17, 2009

Kim – I learned a ton in your blog post. Nicely done. Isn’t the new culture on a global level “living out loud.” From all the controversy surrounding http://www.roseyawards.com campaign, you’d swear it’s like setting one’s hair on fire. Wait, I don’t have hair. Provocative.

Jim
June 18, 2009

Controversy? I can’t believe anyone in any of those cities would take it personally. (Okay, I suppose those people are out there.) I could be wrong, but I’m pretty confident there was no malice intended.

For me, I sniggered more than once, so I say kudos.

And if you can do better, jump to the front of the line and volunteer your time for next year.

PDXsays
June 20, 2009

These are some fairly weighty numbers. Jerry Ketel (Leopold | Ketel) , KJ McAllister, and I touched on this in a converso at the last PAF meeting at Someday Lounge. While in Chicago, or Austin, or NYC as a cr8v you can feel encouraged to assume a mask that fits who you are in a cr8v role (tip of the hat to @JoelGunz), in PDX you are more likely to have a whole wardrobe of cr8v masks – or roles – that fit you sexy, sexy. Rarely are cr8v’s one-trick ponies; here, for-some-as-yet-unquantified reason, the sum is easily larger than the parts; you can freely access and mature simultaneously wherever your interests or talents lay.. lie…load…[cue Grammar Nazi] And I have a sneaking suspicion it relates to Sheldon Renan’s postulated netness… [http://www.slideshare.net/brampitoyo/the-next-moores-law-netness-why-everything-wants-to-be-connected]

But I am wondering – to our tech | OS friends… how do these numbers stack up compared to what’s happening in the Silicon Floral arrangement (nod to Rick Turoczy) with OS | start ups | tech in our fair city? Got a feeling some of these cr8v numbers may overwhelm the tech. I know that they overlap, as some cr8v’s have righteous claim to being inveterate techies and vice-versa. Which c/b telling when it comes to planning and arranging local economy and biz… what cha think?

Dave Allen
June 20, 2009

Kim,

re the title of your post, are you suggesting that Portland’s creative doesn’t “live out loud?” Are we all living under a rock? When I travel and speak at conferences on behalf of Nemo, Portland is effusively praised wherever I go, both here and abroad. So what do you mean by “live out loud?”

When I arrived in PDX in 1999 I came here because of its creativity! I’m still here. It’s time to drop the “chip on the shoulder” b.s. and get on with embracing the amazing creative work that comes out of PDX…

Dan
June 22, 2009

I’ve lived in London, LA, and served a lot of time in Chicago, and the big difference in Portland is the relaxation. People here are chill about work in relation to life. Great things can be done without acting like a coke-snorting trainwreck all the time.

The reaction of those “other” cities to the Roseys site strikes me as the big brother(s) who never expected a snappy retort from their docile little sibling. And now that it’s happened many are crying to mommy instead of getting the joke. Relax and have a pint, mates, we’re still the smaller kid… for now.

Dave Allen
June 22, 2009

Anonymous Dan,

There is no joke, that’s the joke. Go get your pint. I too moved from London, worked in Los Angeles, have traveled the world, so what? The ad campaign has nothing to do with “how chill” we are – I love Portland and I like to create great work just as my friends do in other cities.

Meanwhile Portland’s reputation is paramount to me and the great creative work that Portland produces should not be belittled by statements like “docile little sibling…” And belittling those who create great work in what you call “other cities” and their “coke-snorting trainwrecks” just goes to prove how seriously small town your thinking has become..

PDXsays
June 23, 2009

Isn’t it great we live in a city so small, the bickering gets all “pown u | fear me?”

If you guys think you wrote snap and snark decent copy as comments… you’re both wrong. #sitdownandspitoutURgum

Maria
June 23, 2009

Pretty good post. I just found your site and wanted to say
that I’ve really liked reading your posts. Any way
I’ll be subscribing to your blog and I hope you write again soon!

Joel Gunz
June 23, 2009

Dave, Dave, Dave: Relax, bro! You’re sounding all uptight and not very Portlandish. Let me buy you that pint, aiight?

The way I see it, if Portland truly is the live-and-let-live city it purports to be, then logically, there is room here for those who prefer a more piss-and-vinegar approach. Isn’t that what coexistence is all about? Unless, of course, the actual rule is that we can represent Portland any way we want, just so long as it conforms to your definition of how Portland ought to be represented.

Nevertheless, I wouldn’t ask you to change your viewpoint. In fact, I would encourage you to go with it more fully. For instance, perhaps Nemo Design could volunteer to help with the 2010 Rosey Awards on a pro bono basis, as Anthill — along with a little help from me — has done this year.

It is very clear that there are other Portlanders who would like to see more chutzpah as we promote ourselves to the world. I’m one of them. You can read more about it here: http://bit.ly/13Om6s

Jerry Ketel
June 24, 2009

This is a great discussion. I think the insight of the piece is that Portlanders are often humble. Is that a good thing, perhaps but not when promoting the city’s creative capabilities.

I like the chutzpah and the cheekiness of the Rosey campaign. Why not tweek New York and Minneapolis? It’s all in good fun anyway.

Besides, no one is taking this seriously, are they?

Sure, it is provocative, but isn’t that what advertising is all about?

J.

Dino Citraro
June 24, 2009

In our view, this campaign has drawn attention to a very provincial and brutish side of our creative community, which I hope won’t be applied across the board to the people who genuinely find this type of bottom feeding to be offensive.

As a local company working on campaigns for high-profile clients, we’ve decided to boycott the awards this year and have been suggesting other companies do the same.

Our dignity is better than your awards.

Grant Kimball
June 25, 2009

Hey, Dino. Sorry your firm feels that way, but I’m sure PAF will respect your position. We certainly do. Although I think PAF has expanded the interactive categories quite a bit this year, so it would have been a chance for your team to show off its great work to the creative community. After all, isn’t what that is really about?

Dino Citraro
June 25, 2009

Hi Grant. I’m hoping that it’s actually about a little more than just showing off great work. I know that might be idealistic.

Richard
July 28, 2009

All this talk about how creative and relaxed we are here in Portland and how we live our lives out loud, I don’t know, it all sounds a wee bit narcissistic to me. “We’re creative!” “We are idealistic!”

Ivan Doig said something a long time ago that stuck with me: “We get our work done.” Love that.

Joe Corrado
August 4, 2009

Speaking of creative, Kim, you may be interested to learn that the title of your 6-17 post owes a tip of the hat to Émile Zola (resident of Paris, not Portland), who observed “If you ask me what I came to do in this world, I, an artist, I will answer you: I am here to live out loud.” This concise description of the artistic impulse has been featured on the CentroidCafe web site for the past seven years.

Kim Brater
August 4, 2009

Thanks Joe for Zola’s actual quote. It’s a great one to be sure.

Richard, getting your work done is a given. But getting it done doesn’t mean you’ll be sought after for the work you do.

Leave a comment

WP_Big_City